Catholics can be both of those things, as long as they believe in God and Jesus it's all that matters.
No that’s not all that matters in the least.
Many Agnostic Historians believe that Jesus existed. Jews believe Jesus existed and they believe in God but they aren’t Catholic.
If you’re a pro-choice Catholic you don’t understand that a fetus in the womb is a living, sentient, human being with a soul. Catholics respect life because we believe God made us in His image and likeness out of love. We believe our bodies are His temples and His tabernacles and it is not okay to destroy our bodies.
By being a pro-gay marriage Catholic you deny the Catholic Churchs’ teaching and Gods’ teaching on the sanctity of marriage, the purpose of marriage, the purpose of creation, and the purpose of sex.
For the Basic Tenets of the Catholic Church please see
for more information.
God bless you.